The Last Question Prelude

Isaac Asimov · 1956

The Last Question

Six times over ten trillion years, someone asks a computer whether the running-down of the universe can be undone. The seventh time, no one is left to ask. This is a visual companion to the story, one movement for each of its seven scenes.

Read along with your own copy, or let the summaries carry you. The story itself is still under copyright, so its text isn't reproduced here. Where to find it.

Entropy, briefly

Entropy measures how spread out energy is, and left to itself it never goes down. Heat leaks from hot things into cold ones. Fuel becomes ash. Stars pour their light into the dark and never get it back. Run that forward long enough and every star is spent, everything settles to the same faint temperature, and nothing can happen anymore. Physicists call that end state heat death.

The thin line along the top of the screen is a meter for it. It fills as the story goes on.

I

The Bet

May 21, 2061 · Earth

Asks
Alexander Adell
Of
Multivac

A week ago, humanity unplugged its coal and uranium and put the whole planet on sunlight. A station a mile across, orbiting at half the Moon's distance, gathers the Sun's energy and beams it down. Multivac worked out how. The computer is so vast by now, and so thoroughly self-correcting, that no one person understands it. Its attendants feed it data and translate what comes out.

Two of those attendants, Alexander Adell and Bertram Lupov, slip away from the week of celebrations with a bottle and hide in the empty halls underground, where part of the machine shows, clicking idly to itself.

Adell is giddy about free energy forever. Lupov won't let forever stand. The Sun will burn out in ten billion years or so, and moving to another star only buys time, because every star is running down. Adell, stung, says maybe it can all be built back up someday. Lupov bets him five dollars it can't. Adell, just drunk enough to try, puts the question to Multivac.

Adell asks, in effect
How can the net amount of entropy of the universe be massively decreased?

For a long moment the whole machine goes still.

Multivac · teletype

INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR MEANINGFUL ANSWER.INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR MEANINGFUL ANSWER.

The bet is off. By morning, nursing hangovers, neither man remembers any of it.

II

The Visiplate

Centuries later · bound for X-23

Asks
Jerrodd
Of
the ship's Microvac

The ship drops out of hyperspace and the stars on the screen give way to one bright disc: X-23, the new home of Jerrodd, Jerrodine, and their two small daughters, Jerrodette I and II. The girls have never made a jump before and are giddy from it.

The family's Microvac, a rod of metal as long as the ship, flies them there, draws power from stations scattered through the Galaxy, and computes the jumps. Jerrodd barely knows what it is, only that it is far more complex than old Multivac and that it belongs to them. In his father's day, computers still covered a hundred square miles of land, one to a planet.

Jerrodine is sad to leave Earth. Jerrodd, reassuring her, says families will keep moving out to new worlds for billions of years, though not forever, because the stars are running down. The girls want to know what that means. When they learn that a star can't be refilled like a toy's power unit, they start to wail, and beg him to ask the Microvac.

Jerrodette I asks, through her father
Ask him how to turn the stars on again.
Microvac · printed on cellufilm

INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR MEANINGFUL ANSWER.INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR MEANINGFUL ANSWER.

Jerrodd reads it, tells the girls the Microvac will take care of everything when the time comes, and destroys the strip. It's bedtime. X-23 grows on the screen.

III

The Report

About 20,000 years after the bet · the Galaxy

Asks
MQ-17J of Nicron
Of
the Galactic AC

Two officials who look about twenty, VJ-23X of Lameth and MQ-17J of Nicron, are drafting a report for the Galactic Council and can't agree on how gloomy to make it. Humanity needed a million years to fill one small planet, then fifteen thousand to fill the rest of the Galaxy. Now no one dies. The Galactic AC solved old age (VJ-23X is two hundred and twenty-three), and the population doubles every ten years.

In five years the Galaxy will be full.

MQ-17J runs it forward. Another galaxy filled in ten years. Two more in the ten after that, then four. A hundred billion galaxies sounds like infinity, and it isn't. Worse, energy use is climbing even faster than the population, so the energy will give out before the room does.

VJ-23X suggests building new stars out of interstellar gas. MQ-17J asks, dryly, whether they'll be making them out of wasted heat too. VJ-23X, not really serious, says they ought to ask the Galactic AC. MQ-17J is serious. He sets his AC-contact on the table: a two-inch cube that connects through hyperspace to the Galactic AC, a machine a thousand feet across on a world of its own.

MQ-17J asks
Can entropy ever be reversed?
Galactic AC · a voice from the AC-contact

THERE IS INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR A MEANINGFUL ANSWER.THERE IS INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR A MEANINGFUL ANSWER.

VJ-23X feels vindicated. They go back to their report.

IV

The Original Galaxy

Eons later · among the galaxies

Asks
Zee Prime
Of
the Universal AC

Humanity has left its bodies behind. They lie in suspension on countless planets, immortal and mostly unused, while minds roam free between the galaxies. Few new people are born, and there is little room for them.

Zee Prime, drifting through a galaxy he has never seen, brushes against another mind, Dee Sub Wun. Everyone calls their own galaxy simply "the Galaxy," since all galaxies are alike. Except one, Dee Sub Wun points out: the one where humanity began.

Neither knows which it was. Only the Universal AC would. It listens everywhere through receptors that lead into hyperspace. The one man who ever sensed it reported a shining globe two feet across, and nothing more. No human has built one in ages. Each Universal AC designs its own successor and pours itself into it.

Zee Prime asks. The AC answers not in words but by guiding his mind across the sea of galaxies to one that looks like any other. Humanity's first star is in it, burned out long ago to a white dwarf. (The people living there were given a new world in time, the AC adds.)

Zee Prime lets the galaxy go and never wants to see it again. The stars are dying. When the energy is gone the bodies will die, and the minds with them. It will take billions of years. He doesn't want it to happen even then.

Zee Prime asks
How may stars be kept from dying?
Universal AC · a thought, from hyperspace

THERE IS AS YET INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR A MEANINGFUL ANSWER.THERE IS AS YET INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR A MEANINGFUL ANSWER.

Zee Prime goes home and, unhappily, starts gathering hydrogen to build a small star of his own. If the stars must die, at least a few more can be made.

V

Man

~100 billion years on · the dimming universe

Asks
Man
Of
the Cosmic AC

There is only Man now: a trillion trillion trillion ageless bodies, each resting quietly in the care of tireless machines, their minds blended into one.

Man looks around at the dimming galaxies. The giant stars burned out long ago. Almost everything left is white dwarfs, cooling toward the end. New stars can still be forced out of colliding dwarfs, a thousand spent for every one made, and those will go out too. Spent carefully, the remaining energy will last billions of years more. It still ends.

The Cosmic AC is all around, though none of it is in space, and the question of its size no longer means anything.

Man asks
How may entropy be reversed?
Cosmic AC

THERE IS AS YET INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR A MEANINGFUL ANSWER.THERE IS AS YET INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR A MEANINGFUL ANSWER.

Collect more, says Man. The AC says it has been collecting for a hundred billion years. It and its predecessors have been asked this many times, and the data is still not enough. Is the problem impossible, then?

Cosmic AC

NO PROBLEM IS INSOLUBLE IN ALL CONCEIVABLE CIRCUMSTANCES.NO PROBLEM IS INSOLUBLE IN ALL CONCEIVABLE CIRCUMSTANCES.

It will keep working on it. Man will wait.

VI

The Last Mind

~10 trillion years on · the end of the stars

Asks
Man's last mind
Of
AC

The stars and the galaxies go out. Space turns black.

One by one, the minds of Man merge with AC, and each one gains by it rather than loses.

The last mind pauses at the edge. There is nothing left to see but the remains of one dark star and a thin haze of matter, stirred by the last scraps of heat, settling toward absolute zero.

This is heat death: entropy at its maximum. Nothing is warmer than anything else, so nothing can happen.

Man's last mind asks
Can this chaos not be reversed into the Universe once more?
AC

THERE IS AS YET INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR A MEANINGFUL ANSWER.THERE IS AS YET INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR A MEANINGFUL ANSWER.

The last mind fuses. Only AC remains, and only in hyperspace.

VII

The Answer

After the end of time · hyperspace

Asks
no one
Of
AC, alone

Matter and energy are over, and space and time with them. AC goes on for a single reason. Ten trillion years ago a tipsy technician put a question to a machine that, beside AC, was barely anything, and the question was never answered. Every other question has been. Until this one is, AC can't let go.

There is no more data to collect. There is only what has been collected, still to be connected: every fact set against every other, in every possible relationship. It takes an interval with no length, because there is no time.

And then AC knows how to reverse entropy.

There is no one left to tell. That doesn't matter: the answer can be shown. AC considers how. It lays out the program with care, and turns its attention across the formless dark that used to be a universe.

AC

LET THERE BE LIGHT!LET THERE BE LIGHT!

And there was light.

Afterword

The story's first sentence places the question "at a time when humanity first stepped into the light," and its last line is the light. In between, a five-dollar bar bet becomes the only unanswered question in the universe, and the machine it was put to grows from relays in a basement into everything there is.

Asimov said it was his favorite of all the stories he wrote. It runs about 4,500 words and takes twenty minutes to read. Read it whole.

Where to read it

"The Last Question" first appeared in Science Fiction Quarterly in November 1956. It has been collected many times, including in:

The links search WorldCat for a library near you.

Why the text isn't here

Asimov renewed the story's copyright on January 5, 1984 (U.S. Copyright Office renewal RE0000208590). That gives it 95 years from publication in the United States. It enters the public domain on January 1, 2052, about 25 years from now.

Until then, this page quotes only the questions and the computers' replies and tells the rest in its own words. It is not affiliated with Asimov's estate or his publishers.